✕
Free to join

Join 12,000+ young professionals

Be first to hear about the best entry and junior-level roles and our events, every week.

You're in! Check your inbox, your first jobs email is on its way.
Something went wrong. Please try again.

Apprenticeships vs Graduate Schemes: Which to Hire?

Apprentice hiring keeps growing while graduate hiring barely recovers. Here's how the two routes compare and how to choose for each role.

Apprenticeships vs Graduate Schemes: Which to Hire?
  • Apprentice hiring rose 8% in the ISE 2025 survey while graduate hiring fell 8%.
  • Graduate hiring recovered 4% in 2026, but only 0.8% outside six big employers.
  • Graduate roles average 141 applications each, and more graduates are applying for school leaver roles.
  • Apprenticeship starts are up 8.7%, but starts among under-19s fell 5.4%.
  • Choose the route by the job, not the scheme, and market apprenticeships as a first choice.

Every early careers team hits the same budget question sooner or later: should our next entry-level hires be apprentices or graduates? The short answer to apprenticeships vs graduate schemes is that it depends on the job, the skills you need and who you want to reach. But the numbers have shifted, and the old default of "graduate scheme first" no longer holds.

Here is what the data says, how the two routes compare in practice, and how to decide which one fits each role.

Apprenticeships vs graduate schemes: what the numbers say

The Institute of Student Employers (ISE) Student Recruitment Survey 2025, published in October 2025, found graduate hiring fell 8% while apprentice hiring rose 8%, according to Times Higher Education. Apprentice numbers have grown every year since the ISE began tracking them in 2015. Among employers that hire both, the ratio fell from 2.3 graduates per apprentice to 1.8, and was forecast to drop to 1.6.

The 2026 survey, published in October 2026, showed graduate hiring recovering slightly, up 4% in 2025-26. But as The Telegraph reported, growth was just 0.8% once six large employers were taken out. We covered the wider findings in our breakdown of the ISE Student Recruitment Survey 2026.

Official figures point the same way. Department for Education statistics published on 16 July 2026 show 308,770 apprenticeship starts in England between August 2025 and April 2026, up 8.7% on the same period a year earlier. Degree level apprenticeships at levels 6 and 7 rose 8.4% to 53,940 starts.

There is a catch. Starts among under-19s fell 5.4% over that period, while starts among people aged 25 and over rose 17.5%. A big share of apprenticeship growth is existing staff being upskilled, not young people getting a first job.

How the two routes compare

Competition for places

The 2025 ISE survey, as reported by Personnel Today, found graduate roles averaged 140 applications per vacancy, against 89 for apprenticeships and other school leaver roles. In 2026, graduate roles averaged 141 applications, rising to 172 in London.

The lines between the two are blurring. In the 2026 survey, 62% of employers reported more university leavers applying for roles aimed at 16 to 18 year olds, up from 40% the year before. Graduates are not waiting for the perfect scheme any more. They are applying wherever the door is open.

Pay and progression

The median graduate starting salary was £33,000 in the 2025 survey, against £24,000 for school and college leavers. Three years in, salaries had grown 37% on average for graduates and 39% for school and college leavers. The gap is real at the start, but the early pay growth is similar.

Cost and funding

Graduate schemes come out of your own budget. Apprenticeship training can be paid for through the Growth and Skills Levy. The government's employer factsheet, published on 2 September 2026, says apprenticeships for 16 to 24 year olds are fully funded depending on the apprentice's age and the size of the employer. It also lists a £2,000 incentive for each foundation apprentice recruited. Foundation apprenticeships typically last 8 to 12 months and cover sectors including digital, retail, hospitality, engineering and health and social care.

Funding is narrowing at the top end. From 1 January 2026, level 7 apprenticeship funding is limited to people aged 16 to 21, plus under-25s who are care leavers or have an EHC plan. If you planned to use level 7 apprenticeships for graduates in their mid twenties, check the rules first.

More change may be coming. The Milburn Review, published on 17 November 2026, recommends a major expansion of apprenticeships for under-25s. We set out what it asks of employers in our guide to the Milburn Review.

When each route makes sense

Apprenticeships tend to work best when the role has a clear, trainable skill set: data, digital, sales, finance operations, engineering, customer service. They also suit roles outside London, where local talent may not have gone to university, and businesses that want to reach young people who skipped university because of the cost.

Graduate schemes tend to suit roles that need broad analytical skills from day one, rotational programmes building a future leadership pipeline, and professions where a degree is a genuine entry requirement rather than a habit.

Plenty of employers now run both. The smartest go a step further and design one entry route with different starting points. A school leaver, an apprentice and a recent graduate can join the same team, with the training adjusted to where each person starts.

What this means for your hiring

We hear this question from TA and early careers leaders at almost every TA Tribe event. Here is where we land.

  • Start with the job, not the scheme. Write down what the person will actually do in month six. If it is a practical skill you can teach, an apprenticeship is probably the better fit. If it needs broad judgement across teams from the start, a graduate route may suit better.
  • Stop marketing apprenticeships as second best. Young people, and their parents, still carry a stigma about apprenticeships. Show the career path, the pay progression and real apprentices talking about their work, ideally on video.
  • Be clear on who can apply. With so many graduates applying for school leaver roles, spell out eligibility. If a recent graduate can apply for your apprenticeship or 12 month internship, say it loudly in the advert.
  • Check who your levy is really funding. If most of your starts are existing staff over 25, your levy is not building a young talent pipeline. Ring-fence part of it for first jobs.
  • Reach beyond the usual channels. Both routes fail if the same people keep applying. Many of the 12,000 young people in our community never went near a careers fair. Meet them where they already are: communities, WhatsApp groups and in-office events.

The best early careers programmes we see do not pick a side. They pick the right route for each role, and they market every route like it matters.

What is the difference between an apprenticeship and a graduate scheme?

An apprenticeship is a paid job with structured training, often funded through the Growth and Skills Levy, and no degree is needed to start. A graduate scheme is an employer-funded entry programme for people who have finished a degree.

Do graduates earn more than apprentices?

At the start, usually yes. In the ISE 2025 survey the median graduate starting salary was £33,000 against £24,000 for school and college leavers, but pay grew at a similar rate over the first three years.

Can graduates do an apprenticeship?

Yes, in many cases. Graduates can start apprenticeships, but funding rules vary. From 1 January 2026, level 7 apprenticeship funding is limited to 16 to 21 year olds, plus some under-25s who are care leavers or have an EHC plan.

Apprenticeships vs Graduate Schemes: Which to Hire?
Milburn Review: What Employers Need to Know on Youth Hiring
Graduate Hiring Is Back Up, but Internships Are Being Cut
AI-Written CVs Are Slowing Hiring. Here's What Works